Some folks love their cars, so much that they spend every penny they earn (and even some money they don't have) on them. Others hate cars and would be perfectly happy never getting behind a wheel. I suspect, however, that most people have a love/hate relationship with vehicles - they value the convenience but dislike the cost. Owning a car isn't cheap -
AAA released a report this year that indicates the average cost of owning a car is between $7100 and $9100 per year, depending on the make and model. The
Bureau of Labor Statistics says that cars are the second biggest expense for average Americans behind homes and home mortgages. Is it worth it? To car lovers, the cost can always be justified; but to more and more, the answer is starting to switch to "no".
"No, it can not be done" is often the answer I get to the question:
is it possible to live comfortably without a car? A recent Washington Post front page article does a good job explaining how we got where we are and presumably why so many people feel that it can not be done. Nevertheless, I think it can, you just need to be in the right place. Some cities will make progress in the next few years to make it easier to live comfortably without a car, but in America we want instant gratification, and having studied this question for months now, I've concluded that there are 5 cities in the United States where you can currently live comfortably without a car.
How did these cities get this way? They emphasized three things: public transit, bicycling, and car sharing. They did not necessarily emphasize each equally, some are more heavily geared toward bicycling and others transit, but most are integrated in some way. For example, bicyclists use transit to extend trips and shared cars are often parked at rapid transit stations. Ultimately, these measures allow for a lifestyle that is promising and rewarding, even without your own car.
Before I give you the list, I must say this: I know there will be folks out there who will read this and think, I
do live in one of these cities, and I
could not live comfortably without a car. If you live or work in an exurb of one of these cities, it very well could be the case. However, I'm not making the argument that everyone who lives in these metro areas
does live comfortably without a car, only that they
could. Where you live and where you work are decisions that were made in the past in some cases cannot easily be altered. However, when evaluating future job offers, you might take into consideration factors like where a job is located, in addition to factors like salary and benefits. When evaluating where to live, you might take into consideration how connected a neighborhood is to where you work and like to spend time, rather than just how nice the house is and who the neighbors are. That said, Honorable mention goes to Boston and Philadelphia, although they still have some progress to make. Here you go...
5. PortlandPortland... the bicycle capital of the USA. According to the
Census Bureau, 3.5% of commuters in Portland use bicycles to get around. While that number may seem on the low end, consider that the national average is only 0.4% and and bicycle hostile cities like Dallas and Oklahoma City are only 0.2%. The
MAX Light Rail system opened in the mid 1980s and has been expanding ever since. MAX is one of (maybe the only?) light rail systems in America that has hooks dedicated to bicycles, and many cyclists use light rail to extend trips. Portland was also a pioneer in car sharing, when Car Sharing Portland (later
Flexcar and eventually
Zipcar) was founded in 1998.
4. Bay AreaOn a recent visit from Dallas to San Francisco I found myself sitting next to a friendly woman from Oakland. She had lots of great things to say about the area and plenty of recommendations for things to see and do. Most notably, she recommended against renting a car during the trip (I wasn't planning on it anyway) and told me that she and her husband had been living happily in Oakland for years without owning a car. They get around by bicycle, and for long trips they combine biking with the
Bay Area Rapid Transit. It didn't seem like she was alone - I spotted dozens of bicyclists on the BART that night, which was interesting to say the least, especially because it was already after 11:00pm. Some parts of the Bay Area still have progress to make. Silicon Valley is somewhat popular with bicyclists but severely lacks transit access. Zipcar has a presence in San Fransisco, Oakland and Stanford, but car sharing in other parts of the Bay is slim pickings.
3. ChicagoIf you ask a native of Chicago to describe
the L, they will probably tell you that the L
IS Chicago. The century old rapid transit system is still going strong. It is only one of 2 systems in the United States that runs 24/7 and as such, is a reliable means of transportation, regardless of the day or time. Chicago's leadership has been strong on bicycles. Mayor Daley has said that he wants to make Chicago the "
city that bikes". Bike commuters claim they can beat vehicles commuters from the north side of Chicago to the Loop by utilizing Chicago's beautiful lake front trails; and the
McDonalds Cycle Center provides showers for bicycle commuters, lockers, and a maintenance facility. Zipcar has a decent presence in Chicago, with most of the cars clustered downtown and in urban neighborhoods like Lincoln Park and Wicker Park.
2. Washington DCDespite its criticisms,
Metro is undoubtedly the most successful post-war transit system in America. The rail system, despite consisting of only 5 lines, has the second highest ridership in the country and it does a fairly thorough job of providing access to key neighborhoods in Washington, Virginia and Maryland. Zipcar has a strong presence in the area, with most of the cars clustered around Metro stations, making it easy to access a car, regardless of what part of the city you find yourself in. Bicycling is less popular than in other parts of the country. Unfortunately, Washington was hard hit by sprawl problems, and monster-truck SUVs still make their ways into the city from the exurbs, making life less than ideal for cyclists in the nation's capital.
1. New York CityWhat can I say? Everybody knows that only a fool would own a car in Manhattan, right? Between the Subway, the cabs, and the fact that everything you could ever need is within walking distance, it just isn't necessary.